top of page
Search

Is the CCRC guilty of perverting the course of justice?

empowerinnocent
27 minutes ago
14 min read

Jeremy Bamber


Quite possibly, yes, according to the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) website, meaning that the Criminal Cases Review Commission (CCRC) might well have a case to answer.


The CPS website says:


The offence of perverting the course of justice is committed when an accused:

  • does an act or series of acts;  

  • which has or have a tendency to pervert; and 

  • which is or are intended to pervert; 

  • the course of public justice.


It goes on to give some examples of what may amount to a charge of perverting the course of justice including:


  1. concealing or destroying evidence or providing a false alibi;

  2. assisting others to evade arrest for a significant period of time.


In this article, I make a case for how the CCRC can be viewed as potentially meeting all of the criteria listed above and how it has possibly enabled a number of persons to evade arrest in the case involving Jeremy Bamber.


When a person has been wrongly convicted, the 'course of public justice' clearly relates to attempts to provide the Court of Appeal (CoA) with reasons to reexamine the case and quash the conviction if the CoA is persuaded of the innocence of the applicant / the unsafety of the conviction


Logically, any actions that prevent exculpatory evidence being placed before the CoA pervert the course of justice. CCRC Case Review Managers (CRMs) must consider such legislation as s. 28 of the Criminal Appeal Act 1968, which requires that evidence admissible in the Court of Appeal must be ‘fresh’, understood generally as evidence or argument that was not or could not have been available at the time of the original trial. This would, in general, involve diligent investigation by CCRC staff, but there is a significant obstacle – the CCRC employs former senior police officers with the potential to block any determined investigator from uncovering fresh evidence. That is, senior police officers steeped in the culture of policing, aware of the multiple methods the police employ to secure a ‘result’ – i.e. the conviction in court of offenders irrespective of whether evidence has been obtained by nefarious means. Just below 10% of CCRC staff (in 2022) were former police officers (see here). The CCRC told me that:


'Amongst the casework staff are a number of former police officers who bring valuable knowledge and experience which supports us in finding and investigating possible miscarriages of justice.'


In most miscarriages of justice there is a significant degree of police malpractice, i.e. the ‘fitting up’ of the suspect(s) by investigative officers developing a theory of guilt and then seeking evidence to support their theories. In hiring retired senior police officers, does the CCRC really believe that upon retirement these officers immediately, like chameleons, replace a lifetime of eager prosecutorial predisposition and suddenly acquire a zeal to expose police malpractice?


The so-called ‘investigative’ processes undertaken in the case of Jeremy Bamber since 1997 by CCRC staff certainly raises valid questions about the points outlined above (at 1 and 2), if the CCRC is not to be deemed ‘above the law’.


When Jeremy Bamber’s latest submission was made to the CCRC on 11 March 2021 his legal advisor, Mark Newby commented:


'This has been a journey that has never forgotten that at the centre of it is a family tragedy and one that still affects all the participants today including Jeremy Bamber. But it has also been astonishing in terms of the picture that is now uncovered and how far away from the original trial narrative this case now presented to the commission is...The audit trail now uncovered raises very serious questions over withheld evidence, misleading of the jury, interference with the crime scene, the movement of key evidence, altered phone records and admitted destruction of original exhibits' (my emphasis).


It is known that former Detective Superintendent Michael Ainsley (deceased) took home and destroyed 27 pieces of documentary evidence related to the White House Farm (WHF) murders and it must be presumed that he did so to deny Bamber’s defence crucial information (see here).


There are a number of persons who were involved in the White House Farm (WHF) sudden violent deaths enquiry who remain alive and at liberty, evading arrest, protected by the failure of the CCRC to investigate information supplied to the CCRC. Some of the persons involved are police officers and some are civilians. There is certainly a case for an independent investigation by a police force to be instigated, and for CCRC staff and others to be questioned under caution.


The CCRC, in an otherwise adversarial criminal justice system is supposed to play a unique inquisitorial role. But you would be hard pressed to find any significant evidence of investigation conducted by the CCRC over the past 29 years, in any of the cases they have processed. I have restricted this article to two examples from the long running case of Jeremy Bamber, but there are hundreds of similar examples among the allegedly wrongly convicted who have applied to the CCRC. Most applicants ask for fresh investigations, but very few have them granted.


Why is it that Jeremy Bamber, in possession of strongly persuasive evidence of police corruption in his case, cannot achieve new investigations conducted by the CCRC? I suggest that it is mainly because since he started applying to the CCRC, his applications have been overseen by former senior Essex police officers who have a visceral interest in protecting the reputations of their former colleagues. Between 2004 and 2012 for the majority of this period, the Head of Investigations at the CCRC was Ralph Barrington, the former head of Essex Police CID[1]. Upon receiving the Queens Police Medal in 1994, Barrington said:


'I believe the award to a large extent reflects the consistent good work of Essex CID. The credit belongs to this excellent body of men and women of which I consider myself very privileged to have been at the head for such a long time.' [2]


We now know that Barrington had been in charge of Case 253 (88), in which four key prosecution witnesses against Bamber at his trial were allowed to avoid prosecution for fraud. Essex Police allowed them to escape prosecution, despite the strong evidence against them. Was it so that their convictions could not be used as a ground of appeal?


Case 253 (88) file was disclosed to Bamber’s QC after his 2002 appeal had ended. A quote from this case file (HOLMES 2 Doc. A49 58/17) stated:


'Essex Police (EP) still felt sensitive about the whole case, our (EP’s) mistakes have been acknowledged, and if he [Robert Boutflour - a key prosecution witness and financial beneficiary of Bamber’s conviction] felt his family were owed something by the force – that may be so, and indeed that was probably the reason for me [Barrington] being there personally.'


Why didn’t the CCRC prevent Barrington from working on Bamber’s submissions from 2004 to 2012? Why did they mislead Bamber and his lawyers about the fact that he had a hand in allowing a fraud investigation (Case 253), begun in 1988, to drag on for many years, and for it then to be discontinued due to the length of time taken to investigate it despite strong evidence of wrongdoing by the prosecution witnesses?


Bamber’s current Senior Manager at the CCRC is also an ex-policeman, who has been shown to have been untruthful to Bamber’s solicitor, and to Jeremy, about what his Case Review Manager had stated to him in various phone conversations.  Months later, he admitted that Bamber’s calls to the CCRC were all recorded and conceded that the Case Review Manager had said what Jeremy alleged he’d said all along. 


With the kind of behaviour practised by Barrington and other retired police officers employed by the CCRC in mind, is it any wonder that valid evidence of Jeremy Bamber’s innocence is not investigated by the CCRC? This is where the conduct of CCRC staff leads to the question of whether they actively seek to pervert the course of justice?


It was recently reported by Simon Hattenstone of The Guardian newspaper that evidence indicated that there were two telephone calls received by PC 1990 Michael West on 7th August 1995, one at 03:26 from Nevill Bamber and one at 03:36 from Jeremy Bamber. If so, Jeremy Bamber is innocent. (see here). The CCRC has already rejected the possibility of two telephone calls.


However, over the many years that Jeremy Bamber has tasked the CCRC with considering his case, the CCRC has never attempted to instigate an investigation. It relies solely on being presented by other parties of existing documentation. This is a fatally flawed approach, to the disadvantage of Jeremy Bamber.


As Simon Hattenstone outlines in his Guardian articles, PC West completed an incident report form known as a C1. Logically, there should only be one such form in existence, started at 03:36 on 7th August 1985. However, no fewer than eight versions of the C1 form exist. All have been written by PC1990 Michael West. Details of the various versions are listed in the endnotes.[3] 


There is no valid, legal reason why PC West would produce eight versions of the form he started on 7th August 1985. Was their purpose to deceive?


Of the eight versions of PC West's Incident Log, only two appear to be identical, though some of the other versions share a number of similarities. In the provisional statement of reasons rejecting his submissions issued to Jeremy Bamber in June 2025 the CCRC stated:


Regarding Appendix 5: Copies of the various versions of the Event Log referred to have not been provided to the CCRC with the submission. The CCRC cannot comment specifically on them without seeing them. It appears fundamentally unlikely that there are eight different original versions of PC West’s Event Log in existence. (see endnote list) Differences between photocopies of the original are unlikely to be remarkable.


The above comment comes from an organisation that boasts on its website:


To help us identify new evidence or legal argument we can use our special legal powers under section 17 of the Criminal Appeal Act 1995 to obtain information from public bodies such as the police, the Crown Prosecution Service, social services, local councils and so on. 

Under section 18A of the same Act, we can seek a Crown Court order to obtain material from a private individual or organisation. Our legal powers mean that we can often identify important evidence that would be impossible for others to find. (my emphasis). We can also interview new witnesses and re-interview the original ones.


Thus, we have an all-powerful government body saying that it is waiting for a voluntary group (the Jeremy Bamber is Innocent Campaign (JBIC)) that has no statutory funding, to provide copies of documents that the CCRC has not located in the 29 years available to it!


How about the CCRC interviewed former PC Michael West, starting with the question: “Michael, why did you create eight copies of the C1 form, and who ordered you to do so?”


The different disclosed versions of the C1 form are located thus:


  1. West Log - Original CPS-MEF 255 5 pages,

  2. Holmes Box 57/61 - West's Log – Result of Action 31,

  3. AP – 04 – 07) West's Log 03:36 – (no ref),

  4. AR – 38 – 04) West's Log 03:36 – (prison file),

  5. Holmes Box 5/47 - Dr Baxendale Exam 5 – 47 (MJW – 1),

  6. Holmes Box 5/61 - Dr Baxendale Exam (SCH – 1),

  7. AT – 33 – 112) West's Log – (City Doc. 142),

  8. Holmes Box 5/51 (No Form C.1).


There are no documents in the above list that have not been available to CCRC staff for the past 29 years, it seems that they just can’t be bothered to look for them. And, it appears that they can’t be troubled to interview former PC1990 Michael West to ask him why he created eight different versions of the C1 document. His responses may be highly revealing and lead to the unravelling of the conspiracy at the heart of the WHF investigation led by Ainsley.


There is one other egregious example in recent years, and worthy of potential prosecutions, in how the CCRC responded to reports that a 999 call from White House Farm (WHF) had been received by former police officer Nicholas Milbank (see here and here). The CCRC failed to interview Milbank and instead allowed Essex Police to meet Milbank and persuade him to deny that he had ever spoken to journalist Heidi Blake (who had recorded their conversation), going so far as to possibly manufacturing a witness statement purportedly made by Milbank before he died of cancer, thus denying any further investigation. Could it possibly be that the senior police officer in charge of Jeremy Bamber’s case submission was instrumental in blocking any CCRC discussions with Milbank in the knowledge that he was terminally ill?


 The process for the CCRC now is surely to:


  1. accept that Hattenstone has demonstrated that there is a strong likelihood that Nevill Bamber telephoned the police at 03:26;[4]

  2. accept that Hattenstone provides compelling evidence that Jeremy Bamber telephoned the police at 03:36;

  3. accept that PC1990 West created eight different versions of the C1 document, the subject of which was “distress call” and that his action in doing so raises the distinct likelihood of a conspiracy to pervert the course of justice. CCRC staff have, over the years, protected him and others from arrest, but it is not too late;

  4. accept that there is prima facie evidence that the case against Jeremy Bamber was created by the use of false evidence by Michael Ainsley, who had no qualms about creating and destroying case documentation for nefarious purposes; and,

  5. INVESTIGATE FURTHER do not just sit back and wait for evidence to fall in your lap. Accept that inevitably this will involve exonerating Jeremy Bamber and identifying others, both police and civilians, of conspiring to pervert the course of justice.


In conclusion, the CCRC was given powers to obtain anything they require to investigate potential miscarriages of justice. Even when this evidence is specified and it is put right in front of them, they repeatedly refuse to investigate and, then, create straw man arguments to justify their erroneous conclusions.


The CCRC is very obviously not fit for purpose, and I believe that one reason is that ex-police officers deliberately sabotage investigations to protect their former colleagues; corruption of this kind is endemic in the organisation, carried out behind closed doors with no one holding them to account.


Dame Vera, your staff are manipulated every day into potentially perverting the course of justice by former police officers, already well remunerated by their pensions in their retirement, who are laughing all the way to the bank while protecting their former colleagues.


By Bill Robertson


Bill Robertson has researched alleged miscarriages of justice for around 20 years and advised on several cases, including the most recent application to the CCRC by Jeremy Bamber.


Please let us know if you think that there is a mistake in this article, explaining what you think is wrong and why. We will correct any errors as soon as possible.



References


[1] Barrington was in overall charge of the notorious ‘Essex Boys’ case. On the 14th of May 1996, following his arrest for drugs offences and two previous ‘no comment’ PACE compliant tape recorded interviews with a solicitor present, one of the accused, Nicholls, agreed to be interviewed without a solicitor and off tape. The interview took place with Ralph Barrington and two DC’s. Barrington had paid out Nicholls as an informant knowing he was in a corrupt relationship with his handlers and Barrington later went on to be a senior employee of the CCRC, to whom Steele and Whomes made their appeals. Barrington was, therefor,e in a prime position to ‘steer’ any CCRC investigations. 

[2] n_9406lw.pdf Essex Police Magazine Page 1.

[3] 1. Fresh evidence reveals that the C1 call log, written by PC 1990 West, which recorded Jeremy Bamber’s 03:36 telephone call on 7 August 1985, were re-created on an unknown date or dates prior to the post-appeal disclosure. No explanation has been offered by Essex Police why copies of the logs were created, when they were created, or who was responsible.

2. At least eight different versions of the C1 log are in existence, only two of which appear to be identical and therefore one is potentially a carbon copy. At first glance the remaining versions appear to be carbon copies or photocopies, however, examination shows that in reality the log has been re-written several times.


The different disclosed versions of this log are:


  1. West Log - Original CPS-MEF 255 5 pages,

  2. Holmes Box 57/61 - West's Log – Result of Action 31,

  3. AP – 04 – 07) West's Log 03:36 – (no ref),

  4. AR – 38 – 04) West's Log 03:36 – (prison file),

  5. Holmes Box 5/47 - Dr Baxendale Exam 5 – 47 (MJW – 1),

  6. Holmes Box 5/61 - Dr Baxendale Exam (SCH – 1),

  7. AT – 33 – 112) West's Log – (City Doc. 142),

  8. Holmes Box 5/51 (No Form C.1).


The numeration of the versions as set out above will be used as a Log reference in order to provide clarity in setting out the differences.



Spelling errors


Spelling mistakes made on the original version should have been spelt the same way had they been carbon copies or photocopies, however Essex Police changed the spelling of “SCEENE” and “TOLESHUNT” when creating the manuscript copies and then spelled “SCENCE” and “TOLLSHUNT” incorrectly for a second time.

Log 1 misspells “CA 5 to SCEENE”

Logs 2 to 7 have the same entry spelt as “CA 5 to SCENCE.”

Log 3 misspells Tolleshunt D’arcy as “TOLESHUNT D’arcy”.

Logs 1, 2, 4, 5, 6 and 7 spell the same entry as “TOLLSHUNT D’arcy”.

Logs 1 to 7 all have the word “dispatched” spelt wrongly as “DESPACTCHED”.



Further differences on the versions of the C1 log


Not only are spelling errors evident on examination of the logs variations, but discrepancies in the evidence content is also apparent, and these are set out below.


Words in bold donate additional wording.


Log version 1

0350 CA7 81 @ SCENE then a large space to the line 0411 VIA IR 10 CA7

In the date 1985 – The 9 and 8 are touching.

One cross is marked on either side and just below ‘Exchange Line’

White House Farm “TOLLSHUNT D’arcy”.

“HAS HISTORY OF MENTAL”

‘CA 5 to Sceene’

There are no brackets around the entry “age 62”

Box labelled ‘RESULT’ is blank

The sender’s address and telephone number not underlined.

There is no signature from the duty sergeant.


Log version 2

0350 CA7 81 @ SCENE then a small space to the line 0411 VIA IR 10 CA7,

In the date 1985 – There is a small space between the 9 and 8.

One cross marked on either side of ‘Exchange Line’, in line with the words

‘WHITE HOUSE FARM, TOLLSHUNT D’ARCY. TEL. MALD. 860209’

‘HAS HISTORY OF MENTAL. ILLNESS’

“CA 5 to SCENCE.”

There are brackets around the entry “age 62”

The box labelled ‘RESULT’ contains: ‘5 Persons killed – CID dealing’

The senders address and telephone number are underlined.

The log is signed by the duty sergeant.


Log version 3

One cross marked on either side of ‘Exchange Line’, in line with words

‘WHITE HOUSE FARM, TOLESHUNT D’ARCY. TEL. MALD. 860209’

‘HAS HISTORY OF MENTAL. ILLNESS’

‘CA 5 to SCENCE’

There are brackets around the entry “age 62”

The box labelled ‘RESULT’ contains: ‘5 Persons killed – CID dealing’

The sender’s address and telephone number not underlined.

Signed by duty sergeant.

 

Log version 4

0350 CA7 81 @ SCENE then a small space to the line 0411 VIA IR 10 CA7

One cross marked on either side of ‘Exchange Line’, in line with words

‘WHITE HOUSE FARM, TOLLSHUNT D’ARCY. TEL. MALD. 860209’

‘HAS HISTORY OF MENTAL. ILLNESS’

‘CA05 to SCENCE’

There are brackets around the entry “age 62”

Box labelled ‘RESULT’ filled in: ‘5 Persons killed – CID dealing’

The sender’s address and telephone number not underlined

Signed by duty sergeant.


Log version 5

0350 CA7 81 @ SCENE then a large space to the line 0411 VIA IR 10 CA7

‘WHITE HOUSE FARM, TOLLSHUNT D’ARCY. TEL. MALD. 860209’

‘HAS HISTORY OF MENTAL. ILLNESS’

‘CA05 to SCENCE’

There are brackets around the entry “age 62”

Box labelled ‘RESULT’ filled in: ‘5 Persons killed – CID dealing’

The sender’s address and telephone number not underlined

Signed by duty sergeant.


Log version 6

0350 CA7 81 @ SCENE then a small space to the line 0411 VIA IR 10 CA7,

In the date 1985 – There is a small space between the 9 and 8.

‘WHITE HOUSE FARM, TOLESHUNT D’ARCY. TEL. MALD. 860209’

‘HAS HISTORY OF MENTAL. ILLNESS’

“CA 5 to SCENCE.”

There are brackets around the entry “age 62”

The box labelled ‘RESULT’ contains: ‘5 Persons killed – CID dealing’

The senders address and telephone number are underlined.

The log is signed by the duty sergeant.


Log version 7

‘WHITE HOUSE FARM, TOLLSHUNT D’ARCY. TEL. MALD. 860209’

‘HAS HISTORY OF MENTAL. ILLNESS’

“CA 5 to SCENCE.”

There are brackets around the entry “age 62”

The box labelled ‘RESULT’ contains: ‘5 Persons killed – CID dealing’

The senders address and telephone number are not underlined.

The log is signed by the duty sergeant.


Log version 8

0350 CA7 81 @ SCENE then a small space to the line 0411 VIA IR 10 CA7,

In the date 1985 – There is a small space between the 9 and 8.

One cross marked on either side of ‘Exchange Line’, in line with words

‘WHITE HOUSE FARM, TOLLSHUNT D’ARCY. TEL. MALD. 860209’

‘HAS HISTORY OF MENTAL. ILLNESS’

“CA 5 to SCENCE.”

There are brackets around the entry “age 62”

The box labelled ‘RESULT’ contains: ‘5 Persons killed – CID dealing’

The senders address and telephone number are underlined.

The log is signed by the duty sergeant.

 
 
 

Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
Post: Blog2 Post
  • Twitter

©2022 by CCRC Watch. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page